Few Americans have heard of the 35=10 rule, but for many
Indian outsource companies it is the critical first lesson they
have learned from dealing with "stupid Americans".
The 35=10 formula isn't based on fact, or science but
is instead based on a popular novel. It could be a lesson in what Indian executives
have learned from
observing American officials and corporate execs.
I learned about the 35=10 rule from from a
report in ITExaminer.com by Subhankar Kundu. The reporter
takes excerpts from a popular novel to illustrate the disdain to
which many Indian workers hold Americans.
“’35 = 10’, the instructor wrote in a big bold letters on the
blackboard”
“‘Remember’, the instructor said to the class, ‘a
thirty-five-year old American’s brain and IQ is the same as a
ten-year-old Indian’s brain. This will help you to
understand your clients. You need to be as patient as you are
when dealing with a child".
As an American, this angered me to the point of frustration but
it does explain why Indian phone workers seem so condescending
and arrogant. It doesn't explain why Indian companies have such
a low opinion of their primary customer.
Indian executives may have formed the low opinion while
dealing with their U.S. counterparts. After all, how stupid can
an American exec be to believe that staffing the company's
consumer service department with people who can barely speak
English would somehow improve costumer relations?
India's belief in the stupidity of Americans is reinforced by
officials in the US, who, plagued with identity theft by foreign
criminals, warn Americans to guard our private information on
the Internet, while state and county officials recklessly post
the same data on government websites and call it a public
service.
Comparing a 35-year-old American to a ten-your-old Indian child
isn't hard to imagine when observing state and county officials
in the U.S. carelessly playing with their new internet toys (and
the lives of citizens) by recklessly dumping constituent data
all over the internet. Indian data mining companies routinely
mine sensitive data from official US websites and marvel at the
stupidity of government officials who never seem to understand
the world isn't entitled to U.S. "Public Records".
American officials should know this. Indian officials
certainly do. Officials in India do not post their constituents
private information online. But they have no problem with
encouraging their citizens to exploit the childish behavior of
some U.S. state and county officials. Indian data mining
companies routinely mine the data and take the position that if
Americans are stupid enough to post the data online, Indian
companies are smart enough to lap up the free data.
Datamining isn't limited to Indian companies. Now their
employees are getting in on the feeding frenzy. A BPOIndia.org
post tells how "Identity theft and Phishing are being promoted
within BPO employees."
The short BPOIndia report says"...[Identity Theft} has become
more prevalent as easily accessible information about
people has become more prevalent".
It seems apparent that India's low opinion of American intellect
is derived from what outsourcing companies have learned from
naive US public officials and greedy corporate decision makers
eager to find cheaper ways to exploit Public Records compiled at
taxpayer expense.
The 35-10 formula taught by Indian trainers was first seen in One Night at the Call Center: A Novel
by Chetan Bhagat where the lead
character recalls his training days as a BPO employee. The book
is a best seller in India.
While outsourcing companies may deny this arrogant and racist
attitude was developed by observing U.S. officials and corporate
executives in action, it continues to be taught to
employees in India.
The instructor concluded his first lesson to new Indian recruits with,
"Americans are dumb, just accept it".
Are Americans really this dumb or childish? No, but judging
the intelligence of all Americans by the simple-minded decisions
of a few U.S. politicians and corporate executives makes it is
easy to understand why Indians might believe we are a
nation of stupid and childish people.
The book says 35=10 helps
Indian agents adjust to American callers. Maybe the American
consumer needs a similar rule to help us adjust to government
and corporate leaders who seem determined to export American
jobs and assets to third world countries at taxpayer expense.