Newsletter Archives The Campaign Tool Chest Home Auctions By State Campaigner's Bookstore
Are American Identities and Documents a Commodity for Worldwide Trade?
The Lives of Three Citizens
As told told and sold on the county Web site
No matter how careful you think you are when it comes to who gets access to your personal information, . . .
Ft. Bend County Refuses Open Records Request That Could Implicate Clerk in Federal Privacy Violations
Charges allege there is no state law to support a $1-per-page fee for printouts of digital records
allegedly sold 32 years worth of real estate documents.
Citizens react with outrage, lawsuits
Sunday, January 22nd, 2006
By David Bloys / News for Public Officials
From Fort Bend County, Texas to Oneida County, New York, citizens reaction to local government publishing their records online is consistently unfavorable. In letters to local newspapers and letters to legislators, concerned citizens are calling for the removal of their sensitive information or removal of the offending official. In an increasing number of cases, outraged citizens are resorting to lawsuits.
When Oneida County Clerk Richard Allen (NY) made the move to post county records online, the response was unanimously negative. Allen said he made the decision to post the images online in response to demands from the public for easier access. Allen must have been listening to a public far outside the jurisdiction of Oneida County. In letters to the Utica Observer Dispatch, local citizens blasted the County Clerk.
- most outrageous thing I have ever heard of.
- ridiculous, if not criminal
- this is a total invasion of a person's privacy
- it may benefit a few, but certainly contributes to the jeopardy of the rest
- I for one, am not happy and I will not vote for anyone affiliated with him (Allen)
- Mr. Allen has put many of us in danger, due to his political ambitions
- A very dangerous decision
- putting public-record documents online approaches the most despicable of the worst
In Allegheny County Pennsylvania Chief U.S. District Judge Donetta W. Ambrose requested the removal of the names and addresses of a hundred local judges from the county's real estate Web site. This came in the wake of the murder of a federal judge's family in Chicago. McCandless police Chief Gary Anderson, president of the Allegheny County Chiefs of Police Association followed with a request the names of local officers also be removed.
In a case that may mark the first of many, Cynthia Lambert filed a federal lawsuit against Hamilton County Ohio after an identity theft ring confessed to gathering the information they needed on their victims from the county web site. Hamilton County Clerk of Courts Greg Hartmann had previously removed 320,000 traffic tickets from the web site when local police notified him the web site established by his predecessor was facilitating the criminal activity. The Hamilton County web site gets 60 million hits annually. News for Public Officials visited the site in February 2005, over a month after the clerk removed the traffic tickets. In a matter of minutes and a few clicks of the mouse, we found social security and bank account numbers on several local residents.
In March of 2005 acting on behalf of a local nurse, the Alaska affiliate of the American Civil Liberties Union filed a lawsuit seeking to bar state officials from publishing contact information for licensed nurses in its online searchable database, on its website, or on informational CDs. At issue was the nurses name and home address. When the nurse first moved to Alaska she likely felt safe from the man who assaulted her in Massachusetts. When the state of Alaska published her home address to the Internet she immediately asked them to remove it. The requests continued for two years before the nurse resorted to a suit against the state.
In most states (including Texas), the law does not require local government to publish the records, it requires the clerks to make them available, not put them on the Internet. But inevitably when officials are caught putting sensitive information online, they blame the law or their own citizens.
Dianne Wilson (TX) for example, told News for Public Officials, "the public needs to be better educated". Wilson claims a doctorate from a school the U.S. General Accounting Office has labeled a diploma mill. Before acquiring her "PhD", Wilson filed records with the county that include social security numbers, medical and psychological profiles on her own family. Now, as "Dr." Dianne Wilson, Fort Bend County Clerk, she publishes the information over the Internet and sells it in bulk for commercial use.
Last May, KHOU reporter Shern-Min Chow asked Wilson why she was putting the records of her citizens online, she dodged the question by blaming Texas laws that prevent her from redacting information from government documents. Wilson is not required to put the documents on the Internet. She is only required to make them accessible at the courthouse.
Readers in Fort Bend County are reacting to articles and editorials concerning what Wilson calls her "aggressively progressive" approach to publishing the documents online. In Clyde King's column, "A sense of real danger, he points out the two main lies her apologists use in defending Wilson, "she has to do it," and everybody else is doing it". The first falsehood is bunk and the second shows a lack of information on Wilson's part. King points out possible legal issues that are likely to arise from Wilson's bad decision and says, "I understand several county residents are considering a class-action lawsuit over their personal information.
In a letter to the editor, George Isleib of Needville wrote, "Like all other subscribers who possees even the smallest degree of common sense, I was outraged after reading the articles concerning the release of public information by County Clerk Dianne Wilson. . . After Reading Ms. Wilson's personal information page on the county Web site, I'm convinced that she cares about little except expanding her questionable resume. Any concern she may express for the well-being of county citizens is about as real as her diploma mill PhD. . . This egregious action by our County Clerk should be a wakeup call for all of us, and I urge everyone to contact Ms. Wilson and other county leaders to demand changes, Then, hopefully after the next election, Ms. Wilson can shop her resume while looking for another job."
It seems very clear the people do not want their officials to publish their documents over the Internet. Officials who ignore the wishes of their constituents in favor of convenience for themselves and those outside the jurisdiction risk anger and lawsuits from the people who elected them.
What you should know to protect your family
Shredding your documents and monitoring your credit will not protect you if your local or state government is publishing the same information on the World Wide Web
Learn what your county government is telling the world about you. Visit FindMyID.com. Volunteer researchers will assist you for free.
Demand your rights. Submit your case for possible class action lawsuit. This group of attorneys offers free legal evaluation of your specific case. Click here for legal help and a free evaluation of your possible case
.Return to News for Public Officials
Get Email Updates Send Comments About This Article